PG Canon · Chapter 01
How to Get Startup Ideas
Good ideas often disguise themselves as bad ones. Learn to notice organic problems, spot schleps, and stress-test an idea before you fall in love with it.
After this lesson
- Stop brainstorming and start noticing problems you actually have
- Recognize schlep blindness as a source of overlooked ideas
- Apply a fast test for whether an idea is worth pursuing
Live in the future, then build what's missing
The way to get startup ideas is not to try to think of startup ideas — it's to notice problems, preferably ones you have yourself, and preferably problems that exist because you're standing slightly ahead of everyone else. The best ideas usually share three traits at once: the founders want the thing themselves, the founders can actually build it, and almost no one else realizes yet that it's worth doing. Drop any one of the three and you get a feature, a hobby, or a business plan competition entry — not a startup.
Where organic ideas actually come from
- Ideas that grow out of your own work, not ones invented in a notebook to sound impressive at dinner
- Being an early, serious user of some new technology puts you ahead of problems other people haven't hit yet — the tooling gaps around a new API, model, or platform reveal themselves to users, not analysts
- Being a genuine expert user beats being a clever outside observer of a market you've read about but never lived in
- The problems worth solving are the ones that annoy you personally, on a recurring basis — not the ones that sound biggest in a pitch
- If it looks 'too small to be a company,' that's often exactly what makes it invisible to everyone except you
Schlep blindness
There are great startup ideas lying around unexploited because they require some unpleasant, tedious, unscalable task that nobody wants to do — paperwork, compliance, integrations, cold outreach, manual reconciliation. Your own unconscious mind will hide these ideas from you, filing them under 'chore' instead of 'company.' The most dangerous version isn't administrative schlep, it's technical glue work: connecting two systems that don't want to talk to each other, which reads as beneath a real engineer right up until someone builds a business on doing it well.
Case
Case: the Friday spreadsheet nobody else saw
A platform engineer at a mid-size company spends ninety minutes every Friday logging into five different vendor dashboards — cloud spend, observability, CI minutes, a couple of SaaS tools — and pasting numbers into a shared spreadsheet so finance can reconcile budget against actuals. No vendor exposes a common export format; some don't have an API at all. He complains about it in Slack for the better part of a year, always as a chore, never as an idea.
Takeaway: He almost missed it because it felt like ops housekeeping, not a product. The unlock came only after two friends at other companies independently asked 'wait, how do you handle vendor spend reconciliation?' — proof the schlep wasn't specific to his employer. The problem had been organic, personally felt, and repeated for a year before he let himself see it as a startup instead of a Friday task.
Signals you might be schlep-blind right now
- You've said 'I should just write a script for this' more than three times about the same task
- The task involves a human manually bridging two systems that should already talk to each other
- You've mentally filed it as 'ops work' or 'busywork,' never as 'thing I could sell'
- When you describe it to someone in the same field, they immediately say 'oh god, yes, that too'
A five-minute idea audit
- Write the idea as the problem, not as the product — 'reconciling vendor spend by hand' beats 'a FinOps platform'
- Name one real person, not a market segment, who has this problem today — ideally yourself
- List every schlep required to actually deliver the solution, including the boring integration and support work
- Ask why a bigger company hasn't already done this — a good answer is 'it looks too small or too schleppy for them to bother,' a bad answer is 'no one thought of it'
- Check whether you are the target user, or at most one honest degree removed from one
Is this idea worth chasing?
You have a candidate idea. What's the honest read?
Read the original
How to Get Startup IdeasPull this one idea: don't try to think of startup ideas — live where problems surface and notice them.
This chapter is a working summary. When the idea matters, read the source once — then come back and do the practice.
Read the original
Organic Startup IdeasPull this one idea: ideas that grow out of your own life and work beat ones invented to sound good.
This chapter is a working summary. When the idea matters, read the source once — then come back and do the practice.
Read the original
Schlep BlindnessPull this one idea: unpleasant, unscalable tasks hide good ideas from the very founders who could see them.
This chapter is a working summary. When the idea matters, read the source once — then come back and do the practice.